Do Games Journalists Need to Excel at Video Games? A Personal Reflection

July 3, 2025 - 00:38

In a recent experience, a games journalist found themselves on the receiving end of ridicule after performing poorly in a video game. This incident raises a thought-provoking question: should games journalists be exceptionally skilled players? The journalist, who shared their experience, highlighted the disconnect between gaming proficiency and the ability to critique and analyze games effectively.

While gaming talent can enhance a journalist's insights, it is not a prerequisite for providing valuable commentary. Many gamers appreciate diverse perspectives, including those from individuals who may not excel in every title. The journalist emphasized that their role extends beyond mere gameplay; it involves understanding the nuances of game design, storytelling, and player experience.

This incident serves as a reminder that the gaming community is vast and varied. Not every player will master every game, and that's perfectly acceptable. Ultimately, the ability to engage with games critically and thoughtfully is what truly matters in the realm of games journalism.