5 Rare Nintendo 64 Games That Are Worth a Small Fortune Today

October 12, 2026 - 18:32

Better check to see if you have these Nintendo 64 games lying around, because they're not only rare but quite valuable on the secondary market.

The Nintendo 64 had a relatively small library compared to its competitors, but a handful of titles have become genuine collector's items. Low print runs, late release dates, and limited distribution turned these cartridges into some of the most sought after pieces in retro gaming.

At the top of the list sits Sculptor's Cut, a Blockbuster Video rental exclusive that never saw a standard retail release. Complete copies regularly sell for over a thousand dollars. Close behind is ClayFighter: Sculptor's Cut's sibling in rarity, the original ClayFighter 63 1/3, which commands several hundred dollars loose.

Starcraft 64, a surprisingly competent console port of the PC classic, often reaches the two hundred to four hundred dollar range. Bomberman 64: The Second Attack suffered from a tiny print run and now fetches similar prices. Worms Armageddon rounds out the group, with sealed copies climbing into the thousands.

Condition matters enormously. Boxed copies with manuals can double or triple the value of a loose cartridge. If any of these are sitting in a closet or attic, it may be worth checking the going rates before assuming they are just old toys.